Uncover ways to tame your inner alignment

In our journey through life, we encounter countless situations where our beliefs, attitudes, and behaviours clash, giving rise to a peculiar sense of discomfort and inner conflict. This psychological phenomenon, known as cognitive dissonance, has intrigued and perplexed scholars and individuals alike for decades. But fear not, for in this article, we delve into the depths of cognitive dissonance, exploring its causes, manifestations, and, most importantly, strategies to overcome it.

Drawing from research and psychological insights, we'll guide you through the labyrinth of cognitive dissonance, offering practical tools to navigate the complexity of conflicting beliefs and behaviours. Whether you're seeking personal harmony, aiming to create a more cohesive work environment, or simply intrigued by the inner workings of the human mind, this article will serve as your compass.

What is cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance was coined by social psychologist Leon Festinger in the 1950s. It refers to the mental discomfort that arises when we hold contradictory beliefs, ideas, or attitudes, or when our actions conflict with our deeply-held values or self-perception. 

It occurs when there's a discrepancy between what we think or believe and how we behave or what we experience. This internal conflict creates a state of mental unease, pushing us to seek a resolution and restore harmony within ourselves.

When individuals experience cognitive dissonance, the discomfort they feel serves as a motivational force to reduce the inconsistency and restore cognitive harmony, such as by adjusting beliefs, altering behaviour, or justifying the inconsistency.

What are the signs of cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance can manifest in various ways, and recognising its signs is crucial for addressing and managing it effectively. Whether in personal life or the workplace, here are some common signs of cognitive dissonance to watch out for:

Psychological discomfort

Feeling a sense of unease, tension, or inner conflict when faced with contradictory beliefs, attitudes, or behaviours is a primary indication of cognitive dissonance. This discomfort can manifest as feelings of guilt, frustration, or confusion.

Selective perception

Engaging in selective perception is a common sign of cognitive dissonance too. People may unconsciously ignore or downplay information that challenges their existing beliefs or behaviours while actively seeking out and favouring information that supports their viewpoint.

Emotional conflicts 

Experiencing emotional conflicts can also be a telltale sign. It may involve feeling conflicted emotions simultaneously, such as valuing job security and desiring career growth, or wanting to support a company's mission but disagreeing with some of its practices.

Rationalisation and justification

Engaging in rationalisation and justification is another example of contradictory beliefs. Someone may attempt to explain away or downplay the inconsistency between their beliefs and actions, finding excuses or alternative explanations to reduce the discomfort caused by the conflict.

Inaction or avoidance

When faced with cognitive dissonance, individuals may choose to avoid situations or conversations that challenge their beliefs or remind them of the inconsistency. This avoidance helps to maintain the status quo and temporarily reduces discomfort.

What are the signs of cognitive dissonance in the workplace?

Cognitive dissonance can also manifest in specific ways within the workplace context. Here are some additional signs that may be more relevant in professional settings:

Job dissatisfaction

Feeling dissatisfied or unfulfilled in a job, while continuing to stay in that position, may indicate cognitive dissonance. This misalignment between personal values, career goals, and the current work situation can create significant internal conflict.

Ethical dilemmas

Encountering ethical dilemmas at work can also trigger cognitive dissonance. When employees are faced with situations where their personal values or moral compass conflict with organisational policies, they may experience significant distress and ethical dilemmas.

Resistance to change

Resistance to change is another common sign of cognitive dissonance in the workplace. Staff may resist organisational changes or new initiatives due to a clash between their current beliefs or established routines and the proposed changes.

What are examples of cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance can be observed in various aspects of life, including personal, social, and professional contexts. Here are some examples, including general situations and those specifically related to the workplace and job application process:

Everyday examples of cognitive dissonance

Smoking and health consciousness: A person who is aware of the health risks associated with smoking but continues to smoke regularly experiences cognitive dissonance due to the conflict between their knowledge and their behaviour.

Procrastination and productivity: Someone who values productivity and efficiency but consistently procrastinates on important tasks may feel cognitive dissonance, as their actions contradict their desired outcome.

Examples of cognitive dissonance in the workplace

A discrepancy in values and organisational culture: When an employee's personal values, such as work-life balance or environmental sustainability, do not align with the values promoted by their organisation, it can lead to cognitive dissonance.

Inconsistency in decision-making: A manager who advocates for team collaboration and involvement, but consistently makes decisions without consulting the team, may experience cognitive dissonance due to the discrepancy between their beliefs and actions.

Examples of cognitive dissonance during the job application process

A discrepancy between job requirements and self-belief: When a candidate possesses the necessary qualifications and skills for a job but feels inadequate or doubts their abilities, it can lead to cognitive dissonance during the job application process.

Choosing between job offers: After receiving multiple job offers, a candidate may experience cognitive dissonance when trying to make a decision. They may feel conflicted about the trade-offs and the fear of regret, resulting in internal tension.

Unrealistic expectations: If a job seeker holds unrealistic expectations about their future role, work environment, or career progression, they may experience cognitive dissonance when faced with the reality of job offers or workplace situations.

What are the causes of cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance can have various underlying causes, stemming from the complex nature of human cognition and behaviour. These common factors contribute to the occurrence of cognitive dissonance:

Inconsistent beliefs or attitudes

When individuals hold conflicting beliefs, attitudes, or values, cognitive dissonance arises. This can occur when they encounter new information that challenges their existing beliefs or when they engage in behaviours that contradict their deeply-held convictions.

Behaviour-attitude inconsistency

When our actions do not align with our attitudes or beliefs, cognitive dissonance occurs. For example, if someone strongly believes in healthy eating but regularly indulges in unhealthy food choices, the inconsistency between their behaviour and attitude triggers dissonance.

Decision-making conflict

Cognitive dissonance can arise after making choices between equally attractive options or experiencing regret for a decision made. The conflict arises when individuals question the validity of their choices and feel discomfort due to the unchosen alternatives.

Social pressure and conformity

Social influence plays a significant role in cognitive dissonance. When a person faces pressure to conform to social norms or group expectations that conflict with their personal beliefs or values, it leads to dissonance.

Information inconsistency

Cognitive dissonance can be triggered by encountering information that contradicts existing beliefs or attitudes. When individuals are exposed to evidence or opinions that challenge their preconceived notions, it creates a conflict between their established beliefs and the new information.

A discrepancy between self-image and actions

Cognitive dissonance can occur when there is a mismatch between an individual's self-perception or desired identity and their actual behaviours. For example, if someone sees themselves as honest but engages in deceptive behaviours, it leads to dissonance.

External and internal pressures

External factors, such as societal expectations, cultural norms, or workplace demands, can contribute to cognitive dissonance. Additionally, internal pressures, such as personal goals, aspirations, or moral principles, can also generate conflicts and dissonance.

What influences cognitive dissonance?

Cognitive dissonance is influenced by various factors that contribute to the intensity and persistence of internal conflict. Here are some key influences on cognitive dissonance:

Importance of beliefs and attitudes

The significance individuals attach to their beliefs and attitudes plays a role in cognitive dissonance. When a belief or attitude is deeply ingrained or holds substantial personal importance, the resulting dissonance is likely to be stronger and more challenging to resolve.

Personal investment

The level of personal investment, whether emotional, financial, or time-related, in a particular belief, decision, or behaviour can intensify cognitive dissonance. The greater the investment, the stronger the dissonance when confronted with conflicting information or alternative choices.

Degree of responsibility

The degree of responsibility an individual feels for their actions or decisions affects cognitive dissonance. When people perceive themselves as having high personal agency or accountability, the resulting dissonance can be more pronounced.

Level of self-esteem

Self-esteem and self-image influence cognitive dissonance. Individuals with higher self-esteem may experience stronger dissonance when their actions contradict their positive self-perceptions, as they strive to maintain consistency between their behaviour and their concept of themselves.

Social influence

Social factors have a significant impact on cognitive dissonance. People are often influenced by the opinions, behaviours, and norms of their social groups. If individuals face conflicting viewpoints or societal pressure to conform to certain beliefs or behaviours, it can contribute to dissonance.

Emotional arousal

Emotional arousal intensifies cognitive dissonance. When individuals experience strong emotions such as guilt, regret, or shame due to the inconsistency between their beliefs and actions, the resulting dissonance becomes more pronounced and compelling.

Availability of justifications

The availability of justifications or alternative explanations can influence cognitive dissonance. If individuals can find ways to rationalise or justify their conflicting beliefs or behaviours, it may reduce the discomfort associated with the dissonance.

Supportive social networks

The presence of supportive social networks can influence cognitive dissonance. When individuals are surrounded by like-minded individuals who validate or reinforce their beliefs or behaviours, it can alleviate the discomfort of dissonance.

What does cognitive dissonance feel like?

Cognitive dissonance can elicit a range of emotional and psychological effects. These are some common feelings and effects associated with cognitive dissonance:

Emotional confusion: Cognitive dissonance can result in emotional confusion as individuals grapple with conflicting thoughts and beliefs. They may feel a mix of emotions such as guilt, anxiety, frustration, or even sadness as they navigate the internal conflict.

Selective perception and bias: To reduce cognitive dissonance, individuals may engage in selective perception, where they focus on information that supports their existing beliefs and ignore contradictory evidence. This bias helps them to maintain a sense of consistency, but it can hinder objective evaluation and learning.

Decision paralysis: Cognitive dissonance can cause decision paralysis when individuals struggle to make choices, due to the fear of making the "wrong" decision. They may experience heightened anxiety and indecisiveness, fearing the potential dissonance that could arise from their chosen path.

Changes in attitudes or beliefs: Cognitive dissonance can lead to changes in attitudes or beliefs as individuals seek to align their thoughts and behaviours. They may re-evaluate their existing beliefs, adopt new perspectives, or modify their attitudes to reduce the conflict and restore internal consistency.

Self-reflection and personal growth: Cognitive dissonance can prompt self-reflection and personal growth. Individuals may engage in introspection, which can lead to increased self-awareness, learning, and personal development.

What is the impact of cognitive dissonance?

The impact of cognitive dissonance can be significant, both in general life situations and specifically within the workplace. The impacts of cognitive dissonance include:

Lower job satisfaction

In the workplace, cognitive dissonance can contribute to lower job satisfaction. When there's a mismatch between personal values, beliefs, or attitudes, and the organisational culture or job requirements, employees may experience internal conflicts, leading to reduced satisfaction with their work.

Decreased motivation and performance

Cognitive dissonance can impact motivation and performance levels. When individuals face conflicts between their personal beliefs and the expectations or demands of their work environment, it can undermine their motivation, engagement, and overall performance.

Impaired workplace relationships

Cognitive dissonance can strain workplace relationships. When individuals experience conflicts between their beliefs or attitudes and those of their colleagues or superiors, it can create tension, communication barriers, and a lack of cohesion within teams or departments.

Hindered career growth

Cognitive dissonance can hinder career growth and development. If individuals are unable to resolve conflicts between their personal aspirations, values, or goals, and the opportunities available in their current job or organisation, it may impede their progress and limit their potential for advancement.

How can I reduce cognitive dissonance?

Dealing with cognitive dissonance requires a thoughtful and proactive approach. Try these strategies to manage cognitive dissonance, both in the workplace and more generally:

Recognise and acknowledge dissonance: The first step is to acknowledge the presence of cognitive dissonance. Be aware of the conflicting beliefs, attitudes, or behaviours that are causing internal conflict and discomfort. Recognising the dissonance is crucial for initiating the process of resolution.

Seek information and knowledge: Gather relevant information and seek knowledge that can help you to understand the different perspectives or options involved in cognitive dissonance. This can involve researching, discussing with others, or seeking expert advice to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the issue at hand.

Embrace open-mindedness: Cultivate an open-minded approach to new information, alternative viewpoints, and diverse perspectives. Be willing to challenge your existing beliefs and consider different possibilities. This open-mindedness can help to reduce cognitive dissonance by allowing for a more flexible and adaptive mindset.

Develop self-consistency: Strive for self-consistency and self-regulation by aligning your beliefs, attitudes, and behaviours to reduce cognitive dissonance. This can involve making adjustments to your actions, revisiting your beliefs to ensure coherence, and seeking opportunities that promote alignment with your values.

Embrace continuous learning and growth: View cognitive dissonance as an opportunity for growth and learning. Embrace the discomfort as a catalyst for personal development and seek ways to expand your knowledge, challenge assumptions, and refine your understanding of yourself and the world around you.

Inner conflict is common, but it shouldn't do a disservice to your job application or decision-making around your career prospects. If you need a helping hand navigating your CV, why not send it for a free CV review from the experts at TopCV?

Recommended reading:

Related Articles: